Can a revised tax system re-balance intergenerational fairness?


A new report has proposed taxing baby boomers to help resolve major issues around intergenerational fairness.

The report, published by the Intergenerational Commission in May, offers ten policy recommendations which would represent a radical overhaul of the UK tax system.

Examples include replacing inheritance tax with “a lifetime receipts tax that is levied on recipients with fewer exemptions, a lower tax-free allowance and lower tax rates.

It also suggests replacing council tax with a “progressive property tax” levied on owners rather than occupants, with a marginal rate of 1.7% on property value over £600,000.

The Commission was set up by the Resolution Foundation to examine the issue of fairness between the generations and has been examining whether generation X (1966-1980) and the millennials (1981-2000) have been left to pick up a hefty bill.

Their report found the post-war generation has the advantage, based on a range of measures including home ownership, earnings progression, personal debt and pension wealth.

As with most think tank reports, this grand plan is unlikely to be put in place. However, some of the proposals could see the light of day, as ministers look for solutions to the problem.

One such example was an idea to generate extra funding for the NHS by extending national insurance contributions (NICs) to people working beyond state pension age. This was reported the day before the Commission’s report was published and Jeremy Hunt, the Health and Social Care Secretary, was quoted as favouring the idea. The Commission’s report went further, proposing that NICs also be charged on private pensions, at a reduced rate.

One point the report makes, which is supported by many other research bodies, is that the ageing population will require more government expenditure on health and social care. The Commission wants that cost to be borne by those who receive the benefit, but politicians may not agree. Either way, the government is unlikely to provide tax cuts any time soon.

It’s important that you have a financial plan in place to fund you through your later years. If you have any questions and would like to speak to a financial adviser, please do not hesitate to get in touch.

You can find the full report here.

Latest news

Find all the latest industry news, all written by our in-house industry experts.

What makes a good financial adviser?

What makes a good financial adviser?

Story 19/11/18

The most recent Financial Lives survey conducted by the FCA revealed that only 40% of people trust financial advisers. With clients appearing to be dissatisfied with the level of service they're receiving, we look at the most important qualities a financial adviser should possess.

Read article
Monthly economic commentary: November 2018

Monthly economic commentary: November 2018

Commentary 16/11/18

Our chief economist, Colin Warren, explores how an increase in US government bond yields is giving way to market volatility and increased investor nervousness, in his latest economic commentary.

Read article
Why is good pension advice so hard to find?

Why is good pension advice so hard to find?

Story 08/11/18

A recent pensions study conducted by YouGov revealed that 45% of people find good pension advice hard to access. We look at the reasons for this and what can be done to help.

Read article
More articles

Get in touch

To discover how AFH's unique approach to wealth management can help you build a better future, please contact us.